Accelerating Nutrition Polices in the Caribbean – Creating Supportive Environments for Healthy Children
September 17-18, 2019, Bridgetown, Barbados.
Building on the November 2017 regional HCC meeting, Beyond the Call to Action Event, which celebrated the success of the Call to Action to prevent childhood obesity and began the process of exploring healthy school policies the HCC hosted a successful meeting entitled: Accelerating Nutrition Polices in the Caribbean – Creating Supportive Environments for Healthy Children on Sep 17-18, 2019 bringing together over 110 NCD voices from the Caribbean and globally to discuss concrete steps to accelerate nutrition policies for the creation of healthier environments for children.
The meeting was HCC’s most diverse to date, bringing together a wide cross section of stakeholders from across health and non-health government ministries, and actors from within the health CSO community and non-health CSOs, regional partners, and critically, a significant grouping of youth voices including school aged children. Ministers of Health and Wellness, Hon. Lieutenant Colonel Jeffrey Bostic, and Minister of Education, Technological and Vocational Training, Barbados and Leader of Government Business, Hon. Santia Bradshaw – provided strong opening remarks further underscoring the political support and commitment to address overweight and obesity in children.
The 2-day meeting was kicked off with the HCC ‘Walk the Talk’ Awards. This is a new initiative of the HCC aimed at recognising excellence in NCD prevention and control. This inaugural year focussed on childhood obesity prevention. The two awardees – Bermuda Multisectoral Team and the Team Jamaica – demonstrated tremendous leadership nationally, regionally and globally through the implementation of obesity prevention legislation and the formation of a social movement across the region in support of NCD prevention.
The Bermuda Multisectoral Team in recognition of outstanding legislative action to reduce the consumption of sugar sweetened beverages (SSBs) in Bermuda through the implementation of a 75% tax on SSBs.
Team Jamaica led by the Minister of Health & Wellness, Jamaica in recognition of outstanding leadership in creating a Healthy Caribbean Mass Movement – Caribbean Moves
Find out more about the awards here.
The meeting was held in collaboration with HCC partners, the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Barbados, the Barbados National NCD Commission, the Barbados Ministry of Health and Wellness, the Barbados Ministry of Education, Technological and Vocational Training, the Barbados Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Foreign Trade, the Barbados Ministry of Finance, Economic Affairs and Investment, Caribbean Public Health Agency (CARPHA), Global Health Advocacy Incubator (GHAI), the World Obesity Federation and COMTRUST.
Creating Supportive Environments for Healthy Children Meeting Concept Note and Programme, view/download.
Civil Society Policy Brief: Priority Nutrition Policies for Healthy Children in the Caribbean, view/download.
Participant List: view/download.
Meeting Report: view/download
Official Opening Welcome Remarks
- Honourable Santia Bradshaw, Minster of Education, Technological and Vocational Training and Leader of Government Business, Barbados view/download
- Honourable Lieutenant Colonel Jeffrey Bostic, Minister of Health and Wellness, Barbados view/download
Presentations
- Keynote Presentation - Ms. Paula Johns, NCD Alliance, ACT Brazil
- PAHO’s Response to Childhood Obesity - Dr. Anselm Hennis, Director, Department of Noncommunicable Diseases and Mental Health, PAHO
- CARPHA 6-point policy package - Ms. Christine Bocage, CARPHA
- CARICOM - Dr Rudolph Cummings, CARICOM Secretariat
- FOPL and PAHO nutrient profile model - Fabio Gomes, Regional Advisor on Nutrition and Physical Activity
- Evidence - Healthy School Food Policies Building on Strong Foundations of Innovative Health Policies - Professor Mary R. L’Abbé, University of Toronto
- Experience in Chile: LAW No. 20.606 "About Nutritional Composition of Food and its Publicity" - Ms. Constanza Astorga Mercado, Ministry of Health of Chile
- National policies for obesity prevention in Uruguay - Mr. Luis Galicia, Ministry of Public Health of Uruguay
- Moving the Food and Nutrition Policy Agenda Forward Canada - Professor Mary R. L’Abbé, University of Toronto
- Conflict of Interest and Nutrition Policy: Spotting Industry Interference and managing COI - Ms. Rachel Morrison, Global Health Advocacy Incubator
- Trade policies - barriers to and opportunities for, implementing nutrition policies - Mrs. Nicole Foster, HCC
- UNICEF’s Strategy for Preventing Overweight and Obesity in Children and Adolescents - Dr. Aloys Kamuragiye, UNICEF
- Recap Day 1, Introduction to Day 2 - Dr. Carlene Radix, HCC, OECS Health Desk
- HCC Advocacy for Nutrition Policies - Mrs. Maisha Hutton, HCC
- CROSQ current status of regional process, updates and next steps - Ms. Cheryl Lewis, CROSQ/BNSI
- Experiences advocating for Mandatory Front of Package Nutrition Labelling - Ms. Juanita James, Diabetes Association of Antigua and Barbuda
- The Heart Foundation of Jamaica Advocating for FOPL - Ms. Vonetta Nurse, Heart Foundation of Jamaica
- Front of package labelling of packaged foods: Development and implementation of Decree Nº272/018 - Mr. Luis Galicia, Ministry of Public Health of Uruguay
- Gradual Ban of Unhealthy Foods & Sugar-Sweetened Beverages In Schools - Mrs. Cecilia Ramirez Smith, Ministry of Education, Belize
- Barbados Childhood Obesity Prevention Project - Mrs. Francine Charles, Heart & Stroke Foundation of Barbados
- Implementing a restriction on sweetened beverages in schools - Dr. Simone Spence, Ministry of Health, Jamaica
- Prohibition of Sale or Serving of Sugar Sweetened Beverages - Mrs. Yvonne Lewis , Ministry of Health, Trinidad and Tobago
- Political Economy of NCDs - Dr. James Hospedales, Defeat-NCD Partnership
- Taxing Sugar Sweetened Beverages in Barbados - Professor Winston Moore, University of the West Indies
- The Bermuda Experience with the Sugar Tax - Mrs. Heather Hollis/Ms. Sara Bosch de Noya, HM Customs Bermuda/Bermuda Diabetes Association
- Exploring the Impact of Sugar Sweetened Beverages - Ms. Nadine Carty-Caines, St. Kitts and Nevis Ministry of Health
- Experiences with Advocating for taxes on sugary drinks - Mrs. Barbara McGaw, Heart Foundation of Jamaica
Photo Galleries
Day 1 see more..
Day 2 see more..
Meeting stand alone banners:
- Stop marketing Sweet Beverages to Our Children
- Mandatory Front of Package Nutrition Warning Labels
- Taxation of Sweet Beverages
- Ban the Sale and Marketing of Sweet Beverages in and Around Schools
- CARICOM Heads of State and Government
A Civil Society Call to Urgent Action for the Caribbean Region to Accelerate Nutrition Policies
The Board of Directors and the Members of the Healthy Caribbean Coalition (HCC), are calling for the urgent acceleration of nutrition policies in the Caribbean to create healthier food environments and address the epidemic of overweight and obesity among Caribbean children. view/download
Goal
To build regional capacity and momentum for the implementation of obesity prevention policies with a focus on: mandatory front of package nutrition warning labels; bans or restrictions on the sale and marketing of sweet beverages in schools; and taxation of sweet beverages.
Objectives
-
- To build awareness among a diverse group of multisectoral stakeholders of regional and global approaches and experiences in advocacy and implementation for:
a. Mandatory front of package nutrition warning labels
b. Bans or restrictions on the sale and marketing of sweet beverages in schools
c. Taxation of sweet beverages - To engage high-level policymakers around HCC’s priority nutrition policies with a view to accelerating adoption and implementation of the same at the national level.
- To explore conflict of interest best practices in response to positive and negative contributions of Industry in the advancement of nutrition policy.
- To develop a meeting outcome statement and call to action which supports accelerated implementation of nutrition policies to reduce overweight and obesity among children in the Caribbean
- To build awareness among a diverse group of multisectoral stakeholders of regional and global approaches and experiences in advocacy and implementation for:
Expected Outcomes
- Increased awareness and understanding among a diverse group of stakeholders of regional and global approaches and experiences in implementation and advocacy for: mandatory front of package nutrition warning labels; bans or restrictions on the sale and marketing of sweet beverages in schools; taxation of sweet beverages; and a strengthened coalition of informed and effective nutrition policy advocates.
- High-level policymakers engaged around HCC’s priority nutrition policies with a view to accelerating national implementation.
- Increased awareness of best practices in managing conflict of interest in response to positive and negative contributions of Industry in the advancement of nutrition policy.
- A meeting outcome statement/call to action which supports accelerated implementation of nutrition policies.
More detail on the Urgent Call to Action, including our infographics and social media visuals can be found on our dedicated web page here.
What is the most important thing we can do to support policymakers to implement nutrition policies which create healthy children and communities?
Create bottom up movement for incentives for healthy food.
Dr Karen Sealey
Trinidad and Tobago NCD Alliance
Our support to policy makers must be in the realm of encouraging strong advocacy and action among our communities and community partners. Launching our "attack" from the ground up is a well documented strategy to achieve our desired objective for action above. We must therefore re-double our efforts in this regard if we are to achieve any meaningful and serious action. Time is of the essence.
Dr Damian Greaves
Grenada National Chronic Non-communicable Disease Commission
To design policies that can be measured and implemented with sufficient capacity and resources.
Mr Lawrence Jaisingh
Ministry of Health, Trinidad and Tobago
Policymakers are traditionally not very good implementors. Civil Society should "insist" on being utilized and tasked with the implementation, while policymakers ensure that standards and policies are adhered to and audited, and provide some (if not most) of the financial backing to implement. The "buy-in" that is needed needs to begin with dialogue prior to policy making, between us and the policymakers. So we need to be accessible and ready to assist policymakers.
Dr Tamara Remy
St. Lucia Cancer Society
Strong national education and Advocacy work at the level of both the policymakers and the other critical stakeholders in the process.
Mrs Francine Charles
Heart & Stroke Foundation of Barbados
To answer this question, I think we should first identify which factors hinder the implementation of nutrition policies in general. From my perspective the main thing why implementation of nutrition policies goes wrong in Suriname, is the lack of collaboration between all parties at all levels (political, policy-making, managerial and operational levels). To overcome this barrier, we can support policymakers by providing them with the competencies, capacities, practical guidance on how to set up an arrangement that connects all parties in a process of committed, continuous collaboration.
Ms Anne Getrouw
Bureau of Public Health, Suriname
Strengthen and harness public support.
Ms Juanita James
Antigua and Barbuda Diabetes Association
Develop an evidence based unified nutrition policy for the region to be implemented in a form similar to the food pyramid.
Dr Owen Gabriel
National NCD Comission – Saint Lucia
Develop effective mechanisms for intersectoral work.
Dr D. Beverley Barnett
Healthy Caribbean Coalition
To set in place engagement channels for young people to voice and be heard across government — when it comes to challenges that affect our youth’s health, such as childhood obesity, young people are in the best position to hold the government accountable to adequately respond and implement policies that will ultimately impact their future.
Ms Hannah Ridgeon
dance4life
Creating "blueprints" that can be tailored accordingly, which should reduce the need for additional resources (such as consultancies) and the time needed to develop and implement policies.
Dr Madhuvanti Murphy
The George Alleyne Chronic Disease Research Centre - UWI
The most important thing is sensitization of the policymakers to the need for healthy food environments and to showcase local research pertaining to obesity levels and lifestyle habits. Policies are needed if we want to create a positive food environment so our children can eat healthy foods.
Mrs Barbara McGaw
Heart Foundation of Jamaica
Nutrition policies play a key role in creating healthy children and communities in general because they assist these individuals to inter alia achieve and maintain healthier diets based on various guidelines.
Dr Fabian B. Lewis
Ministry of the Finance and the Public Service, Jamaica
Create a strong lobby among civil society activists, business leaders, farmers, communities and ordinary citizens to create the level of buy-in by the public at large to give politicians and policy-makers the courage to act decisively.
Ms Teresa Marshall
National Organizing Committee for UNCTAD VX
They key ingredients in achieving the desired objectives are partnerships and collaborations – all stakeholders need to come together across the board – government, food industry, hospitality industry, media, civil society groups, educational institutions, corporate, parents, teachers and the children – the should be continuous efforts to bring everyone together – create a middle ground – recommend, adopt and implement healthy eating habits.
Mr Amitabh Sharma
The Gleaner Co. (Media) Ltd.
Continue to advocate for implementation by providing initiatives and activities for implementation, building their capacity in understanding of the issue, conducting research which shows impact of policies not being implemented. Remain committed and passionate to the cause.
Mrs Mignon Rolle Shillingford
Ministry of Health and Social Services, Dominica
1. Create models for supportive environments.
2. Educate and empower parents teachers and children.
3. Uncourage owernship of lifestyle efforts and projects in schools , churches , communities etc.
4. Create blue prints for the practical implementation of policy.
5. Build body of advocates demanding change.
6. Develop a multisectorial and mulrigenerational approach to this fight.
Dr Diane Brathwaite
The Barbados Diabetes Foundation
To promote intersectorial approach for food healthy environment regulation
To ensure that all key actors can contribute to this agenda
To promote, to support, to establish monitoring and evaluation process on Public policies (nutrition policies, food healthy environment regulation, …)
To establish and support international cooperation between countries (regional network,…) allowing best practices exchanges, technical discussion, technical/political support.
Ms Zohra Abaakouk
Pan American Health Organization/World Health Organization
Ensure an enabling nutrition policy environment by utilizing a multipronged approach inclusive of engagement, education, and empowerment.
Dr Janelle Bryan
Temple Fitness & Wellness Inc.
In an effort to support policy makers in the implementation of nutrition policy for the benefit of children and communities, it is important to partner with policymakers supporting all aspects of the implementation process. Also collaborate with advocacy groups and stakeholders to provide programs and activities to increase awareness of the process in school, churches and by extension the community.
Mrs Christobelle King
St. Vincent & the Grenadines Diabetes & Association Inc.
For any sustainable behaviour change we need to have an intersectoral approach targeting the broader socio-cultural determinants of dietary choices. As NGOs, we can support policy makers through using our platforms to educate and mobilize our diverse target groups on the benefits of nutrition policies and the impacts of healthy choices on quality of life and long-term health outcomes. Gaining community buy-in is critical.
Ms Leila Raphael
dance4life
Clarify what we mean by NCDs to ordinary people (communication).
Mobilise patient organisations and civil society to 'make noise' (Advocacy) using a digital health approach.
Use more political economy analysis to inform strategies.
Dr C James Hospedales
Defeat-NCD Partnership
Host forums for families.
Ms Keisha Gittens
CIBC FirstCaribbean International Bank
It is important to keep abreast of the best practices and the evidence so that we may give the best guidance possible. It is also important to think critically about how various measures may be adopted at the country level to suit the local context.
Dr Aisha Andrewin
Ministry of Social Development, Anguilla
To support policy makers to implement nutrition policies which create healthy children and communities, the following must be done:
– They need to appreciate the importance of the initiative
– Data must be presented highlight evidence
– They must be convinced of economic value
– They must understand how it directly affects quality of lives
Dr Sharon Belmar-George
Ministry of Health and Wellness, St. Lucia
We can support them sharing and promotion at every level of our interaction. When we wait on macro level implementation we forfeit true sensitization and appreciation of the what is at stake. The children form the next generation so they must be aware of the significance of their actions at a formative stage. The conversation must be from a bottom up approach. Community outreach programs, schools, supermarkets, restaurants, churches and social media need to be utilized as a tool to truly promote policies regarding nutrition.
Ms Janine White
CIBC FirstCaribbean International Bank
There are several critical things that can be done to support policymakers to implement nutrition policies which create healthy children and communities. These include: • Having current evidence to support the policy initiatives.
• Suggesting reasonable strategies to achieve the goals.
• Incorporating existing expertise in the implementation of the plan of action.
• Include all stakeholders from the planning stage for buy-in and sustainability of efforts.
• Continuous dialogue.
Ms Christine Bocage
Caribbean Public Health Agency (CARPHA)
Advocate to members of the society the need to choose healthier lifestyles through advertising, and promotional campaigns, thereby making it easier for policy to be accepted and supported by the populace. Once the populace supports the policies there should be no push back and implementation of nutrition policies would be widely supported.
Ms Lavine Small
Heart & Stroke Foundation of Barbados
Build an effective and sustainable partnership amongst the advocates (Public Health – national, regional and international bodies, and like minded civil society organisatons), the private sector (particularly those engaged in food production and processing), and the relevant policy makers (agriculture, health education and finance) to confront the concerns and to develop an agreed plan of action with sequential outputs towards realising the desirable outcome of healthy children and communities.
Mrs Nisa Surujbally
Consultant
Provide technical and step by step implementation support.
Mr Ian Ho-A-Shu
Inter American Development Bank
Work collaboratively to support and share best practices.
Professor Mary R. L’Abbé
University of Toronto
Parent/ caregiver education and capacity building seems to be an area in which we have been lacking. It requires varied and consistent contact and the parents and caregivers population is large. the MOHW is unable to do all that is necessary. Schools have been indicating that they struggle with getting parents to support healthy nutrition related policies. This sometimes derails the efforts of the schools.
Ms Deonne Caines
Ministry of Health and Wellness - Jamaica
?: There needs to be more education and sensitization on the topics of NCDs and Childhood obesity, especially since our cultures are such that NCDs such as Mental Health are not given as much attention in comparison to the more popular types of cancer, heart disease etc. Public education on such would then garner support for the policies being implemented as they would understand the implications of these diseases and why it is important for the government to take certain measures to combat them.
Mr Pierre Cooke Jnr.
Healthy Caribbean Coalition
The most important thing we can do to support policy makers is to ensure that all the programmes are fully implemented in the strategic plans of the various sectors both public and private sector. That is, to ensure that there is a component of nutrition and healthy behaviours and or physical activity, and healthy work environments. Specifically targeting employers, employees, patrons, children, and other community partners.
Ms Nadine Carty-Caines
Health Promotion Unit, Ministry of Health - St. KItts & Nevis
Utilise a health in all policies approach to nutrition policy making. Involve key sectors (health, education, agri, trade, foreign affairs) in policy review, program development and operationalise of policies across sectors. Create tools, and build capacity for joint gap analysis, planning, monitoring of nutritional policies and strategies, with Civil society, professional and regional bodies. Build capacity for documentation, research and policy evaluation. Obtain policy approval at a high level (Cabinet/Parliament) to ensure multiple sector implementation and funding.
Ms Yvonne Lewis
Ministry of Health - Trinidad and Tobago
Share experiences from across the region so that we can reduce potential barriers to implementation of sustainable nutrition policies.
Mr Andrew Dhanoo
The Diabetes Association of Trinidad and Tobago
From the perspective of the education sector, of which I am currently employed, I would say conducting research that provides timely, accurate information to address the current and evolving landscape. From a consultancy perspective, it is also important to provide proven options for various implementation strategies that work best for the communities/societies for which the policies were designed.
Ms Jamie Rocke
The University of the West Indies, Open Campus
Disseminate more information about the negative externalities associated with certain lifestyle and nutritional choices.
Professor Winston Moore
University of the West Indies, Cave Hill Campus
From a youth perspective, it is imperative that we engage in peer to peer education on the importance of a healthy lifestyle because we are more capable of getting across the information to the youth, as we are the youth. One of the biggest challenges in implementing policies is the backlash that will arise from the populous. Thus, if the youth find the policy useless due to a lack of knowledge, there will be issues. So we have to sensitize our peers, who will then sensitize their parents, allowing for a smooth and understood policy revolving around NCD's to be put into effect.
Mr Rondell Trim
Childhood Obesity Prevention Campaign Volunteer
Policy makers usually are hesitant to develop and implement certain policy because of the fear that they will be met with resistance and may have repercussions on economic viabilities of the country. The use of regional interventions such as the development of policies aimed at reducing transfat, sodium and refined sugars in manufactured products as a regional stance may provide the additional support that countries may need. Taxation of imports from outside of CARICOM which are high in those ingredients may be another way to go. Incorporating the above and more into a regional strategy.
Dr Kavita Singh
Ministry of Public Health Guyana
To continue community engagement, parental education and school administrators regarding the behavioural changes and accessibility issues regarding low nutrient calorie dense options as opposed to better food choices.
Dr Asha Pemberton
Ministry of Health, Trinidad and Tobago and Caribbean Congress on Adolescent and Youth Health
Use our platforms to promote the healthy eating agenda, provide our unique technical resources to tackle the issue from all angles and keep the pressure on! Knowing how critical these policies are and how constituents support them is a vital step in ensuring policymakers' determination to continuously move forward.
Ms Shakira Emtage-Cave
dance4life
Perhaps the most important thing we can all do to support policy makers is to continue our advocacy on the subject with a consistent message regarding the critical importance of childhood obesity prevention policies for our country’s future. As the message is amplified and echoed throughout our societies there will be a greater level of traction and buy-in regarding its value proposition which would then provide the basis for our governments to raise the level of priority and hence resources directed at addressing this problem and to provide more credible leadership and sustained action.
Dr Thomas Samuel
Ministry of Commerce, Intl. Trade, Enterprise Development, Investment and Consumer Affairs - Saint Lucia
1) Make a meaningful contribution at the development stage of the policies through sharing ideas, research and information based on experience.
2) Communicating via our social media platforms how the policy has impacted our personal lives and those of our loved ones.
3) Hold policy makers responsible not just for the implementation but also for the enforcement, monitoring and evaluation and communication back to the masses about its effectiveness and was in which the policy can be improved.
Mr Corey Worrell
C2J Foundation Inc.
We need to listen and learn how to communicate our evidence more effectively among political leaders; specifically we need to work with health policymakers to ensure nutrition policies resonate with leaders that may not share our ideologies (about framing as much as evidence). We also need to be braver in calling out political economies that are undermining implementation, and more adept at explaining how the commercial determinants can be tackled.
Ms Rachel Thompson
World Obesity Federation
Agitate for policies that aligned with health policies and best practices.
Mr Danny Gill
Ministry of Health and Wellness - Barbados
As policymakers we must ensure that we lend support to the policymakers that implement policies which create healthy children and communities by efficiently and effectively fulfilling the tasks/actions that we have responsibility for. A chain is as strong as its weakest link, therefore, a further breakdown in nutrition would occur if there are any inefficiencies along the 'implementation chain'. Also, as individuals implement the principles of a healthy lifestyle in our homes, actively participate in the initiatives and by being advocates in our communities.
Ms Camiel Pennycooke
Ministry of Industry, Commerce, Agriculture and Fisheries, Jamaica
Lobby using existing legal framework that supports the implementation of policies supporting healthy nutrition.
Ms Donnelle Christian
Vital Strategies
Initiatives focused on improving aspects of students' well-being in schools such as childhood obesity is gaining momentum. However, efforts are often implemented in silos without the recognition of their interconnection. To continuously advance this, coordinated efforts that integrate multiple components of the healthy school environments must be addressed.
Ms Daisry Higgs
Ministry of Education
When we often speak about policymakers, we think of the technocrats in the Ministries that seek to develop policies. Oftentimes we fail to forget that we too as the general population are also part of the policymakers. We can therefore support the policymakers by getting involved in the development, assist in creating supporting and enabling environments both at home and in the communities and commencing any applicable behavior change as a family unit.
Dr Patrice Lawrence-Williams
Pan American Health Organization
Barbados is a vibrant island nation that has an abundance of natural beauty and hospitality. It is a mostly flat coral island, 21 miles long by 14 miles wide with 70 square miles of beautiful sandy beaches, there are also rolling hills and gullies, with an interesting array of flora and fauna.
Diverse and active, Barbados offers some amazing sights and attractions including submarine tours, catamaran cruises, cave exploration, jeep safaris, heritage tours, exciting nightlife and fine dining.
To enter Barbados, all visitors must have a valid passport and ticket.
The currency of Barbados is the Barbados Dollar (BBD) the Barbados Dollar is fixed to the U.S Dollar and does not fluctuate. ($1.98 BDS to $1.00 U.S.) U.S. Dollars are readily accepted in stores and restaurants.
Please note that it is against the law to wear camouflage clothing and to carry items made of camouflage material.
You can find out more information by visiting the Barbados Tourism Marketing website here.